
December 1, 2006 |
2006-R-0729 | |
COMPARISON OF PUBLIC HEALTH INSURANCE—CONNECTICUT AND MASSACHUSETTS | ||
| ||
By: Robin K. Cohen, Principal Analyst | ||
You asked us to compare eligibility criteria, benefits, and cost sharing requirements for “public health insurance” in Connecticut and Massachusetts before and after Massachusetts passed universal health insurance legislation earlier this year. To the extent possible, you asked us to divide this into three categories: children, adults with children, and childless adults.
This report does not include community health centers. In both states, these publicly supported centers are available to anyone.
SUMMARY
Both Connecticut and Massachusetts have fairly generous eligibility criteria for children in their public health insurance programs. Medicaid and the State Children's Health Insurance Program (SCHIP) provide the lion's share of child coverage, but Massachusetts' Medicaid (MassHealth) program appears to cover many more non-disabled adults than Connecticut. Massachusetts will soon be covering more uninsured residents as a result of a new universal coverage law that includes state-procured insurance for all residents.
Massachusetts seems to require more in cost sharing, even from its lowest-income Medicaid recipients. Benefits for lower income families in both states are provided through managed care organizations and are fairly comprehensive. The new Massachusetts law restores Medicaid coverage for certain “optional services” provided to adults, as well as provides new coverage for smoking cessation treatment. Connecticut does not cover several of these optional services, including smoking cessation treatment.
We should note that unlike Connecticut, Massachusetts has exhausted its federal SCHIP block grant, which could affect the state's ability to offer more coverage to certain higher-income families in its MassHealth Family Assistance program. Historically, Connecticut has had significant surpluses in its SCHIP grant. This grant pays 65% of the state's HUSKY B costs.
PUBLIC HEALTH INSURANCE IN MASSACHUSETTS AND CONNECTICUT
Until earlier this year, Massachusetts' public health insurance system consisted of MassHealth, the major Medicaid and State Children's Health Insurance Program(SCHIP)-funded programs and other assistance geared to specific subgroups of the uninsured population. By far, MassHealth is the largest. Table 1 presents the main MassHealth coverage groups.
Table 1: MassHealth Coverage Types
Coverage Group |
Income Limit |
Benefit Package [1] |
Cost Sharing |
Unique Features |
MassHealth Standard | ||||
Full benefits |
Nominal co-payments for pharmacy, inpatient hospital, nonemergency ER use; exceptions as required by federal law (e.g., children under 19) |
|||
—Pregnant women and children up to age 1 |
200% of FPL |
|||
—Children up to age 19 |
150% of FPL |
|||
—Parents and caretaker relatives of children; disabled adults |
133% of FPL |
|||
MassHealth Common Health | ||||
—Person older than 65 with disability and (1) working 40 hours per month or (2) meeting federal and state conditions |
None |
Same as above |
Premiums when income reaches 100% of FPL; co-pays (see above) |
|
MassHealth Family Assistance (SCHIP) | ||||
—children, some working adults, people who are HIV-positive |
Children qualify up to 300% of FPL; certain adults up to 200% of FPL |
Same as above |
$12 per month per child, $84 monthly cap; co-pays (see above) |
Offers premium assistance only for adult coverage |
MassHealth Basic Health | ||||
—unemployed adults with mental disabilities |
100% of FPL |
Inpatient and outpatient, medical and mental health services (e.g., labs) and emergency ambulance for enrollees in managed care plans |
Co-pays (see above) |
Premium assistance if employer coverage available |
MassHealth Essential | ||||
—adults under age 65 who (1) are not working, (2) have not worked in last year or have worked but not enough to collect unemployment, or (3) have immigration status making them ineligible for MassHealth Standard |
100% of FPL |
Inpatient hospital, outpatient, medical (labs, x-ray), mental health, emergency ambulance |
Co-pays (see above) |
Premium assistance or enrollment in MassHealth managed care plan |
Children's Medical Security Plan | ||||
-children up to age 19 who do not qualify for MassHealth Family Assistance |
300% to 400% of FPL |
More limited service package, essentially primary and preventive care; maximum $750 annual dental limit |
$33.14 per family monthly premium, co-pays ranging from $2 to $8 |
Program can have waiting list if insufficient funding. Families can get hospital care through state's Uncompensated Care Pool. |
[1] For a listing of MassHealth services by coverage type, please see Attachment 1.
The state has also offered coverage for inpatient and outpatient hospital care through its Uncompensated Care Pool (UCP), as well as premium assistance for individuals who are receiving unemployment compensation and can maintain employer-sponsored coverage or private coverage. Both programs are available to individuals with family income up to 400% of the federal poverty level (FPL).
In April 2006, the legislature passed the nation's most far-reaching universal health insurance law. The law includes expansions in MassHealth eligibility and restores program benefits that were previously cut. These benefits include vision care (including eyeglasses), administrative days in inpatient hospitals, substance abuse treatment, dental services, and chiropractors. (Connecticut eliminated coverage of several optional services in 2002.) It also increases the enrollment caps in some of its MassHealth programs.
Starting April 1, 2007, the new law offers an insurance product, Commonwealth Care Health Inusrance Program (C-CHIP), to uninsured adults who do not qualify for MassHealth or Medicare. To qualify for a state subsidy for this plan, family income cannot exceed 300% of the FPL. And very low-income childless adults may be able to get this insurance, without cost sharing, if their income is at or below 100% of the FPL. Many people receiving care from the UCP will now be served by the C-CHIP. Until 2009, the existing Medicaid managed care plans have the exclusive right to serve people in the C-CHIP program. For a summary of the new law, please see OLR Report 2006-R-0285.
Connecticut's public health insurance consists of Medicaid, including HUSKY A and HUSKY B, and State-Administered General Assistance (SAGA) Medical Assistance. The state's Uncompensated Care Pool/Disproportionate Share Hospitals program provides financial assistance to hospitals for providing uncompensated care to residents.
Table 2 presents Massachusetts public health insurance coverage before the 2006 law passed and after and compares it to Connecticut's coverage.
Table 2: Public Health Insurance—Pre- and Post-Universal Health Insurance Reform in Massachusetts and Connecticut
Eligibility |
Pre-Reform—Program, Cost Sharing, Benefits |
Post-Reform—Program, Cost Sharing, Benefits |
Important Features |
Connecticut [1] |
Children in families with income between 200% and 300% of FPL |
Children's Medical Security Plan—$7.80 per child monthly premium, $23.40 family cap; limited service package |
MassHealth Family Assistance—$20-$28 per child premium, $60-$84 monthly cap; full MassHealth benefit package |
HUSKY B—Children in families with incomes between 185% and 300% of FPL; $30 per child monthly premium, $50 family cap once income reaches 235% of FPL; co-payments, with $650 annual cap; full complement of benefits | |
Adults with income between 100% and 300% of FPL |
Adults with income up to 133% of FPL eligible for MassHealth Standard; no cost sharing |
Adults with income up to 300% eligible for subsidized Commonwealth Care Insurance Program (CCHIP) managed care; premiums range from $18 to $106 per month, depending on income. Co-pays apply and vary based on plan. No premiums for people with income ≤100% of FPL. MassHealth-eligible continue to receive MassHealth. (See Attachment 2 for a list of benefits and cost sharing for the C-CHIP plans.) |
Participants eligible for one of four plans. Plan I is for individuals with income ≤ 100% of FPL. Plan II is for those with income between 1200% and 200% of FPL. Plans III and IV offer low- and high-premium options to families with incomes between 200% and 300% of FPL. |
Adult caretaker relatives of HUSKY A children eligible with income up to 150% of FPL; no cost sharing; full Medicaid service package |
Childless adults with income up to 100% of FPL |
Uncompensated Care Pool |
C-CHIP product; no premiums; nominal co-payment; full benefits |
State-Administered General Assistance; income under $500 per month; no cost sharing; services received in community health centers; more limited service package than Medicaid | |
People with employer- sponsored coverage |
Premium assistance for people with incomes up to 200% of FPL |
Premium assistance for people with incomes up to 300% of FPL |
No premium assistance (except rarely used Medicaid Health Insurance Premium Program for people eligible for Medicaid) |
[1] For a complete listing of HUSKY benefits and co-payments, go to www.huskyhealth.com.
RC:ro
Attachment 1: Services Included in MassHealth by Coverage Type
This chart shows the services that the five main MassHealth coverage types offer and the citations to regulations that describe those services in detail. For a listing of behavioral health services through the Partnership, see www.masspartnership.org
|
Services |
|
Standard |
Common |
Family |
Basic |
Essential |
Total number of services |
40 |
40 |
33 |
30 |
22 | |
Abortion |
484 |
a |
a |
a |
a |
a |
Acute Inpatient Hospital |
415 |
a |
a |
a |
a |
β |
Adult Day Health |
404 |
a |
a |
No |
No |
No |
Adult Foster Care |
a |
a |
No |
No |
No | |
Ambulance |
407 |
a |
a |
a |
a |
β |
Ambulatory Surgery Center |
423 |
a |
a |
a |
a |
β |
Audiologist |
426 |
a |
a |
a |
a |
No |
Behavioral health (mental health & substance abuse) |
411, 417,418, 425, 429, 434 |
β |
β |
β |
β |
β |
Chapter 766: Assessments & Team Mtgs. |
439 |
a |
a |
a |
a |
No |
Chiropractor |
441 |
a |
a |
a |
a |
No |
Chronic Disease and Rehabilitation Hospital Acute Inpatient |
435 |
a |
a |
a |
No |
No |
Community Health Center |
405 |
a |
a |
a |
a |
β |
Day Habilitation |
419 |
a |
a |
No |
No |
No |
Dental Services |
420 |
a |
a |
a |
a |
β |
Durable Medical Equipment and Supplies |
409 |
a |
a |
a |
a |
β |
Early |
440 |
a |
a |
a |
No |
No |
Family Planning |
421 |
a |
a |
a |
a |
β |
Hearing Aid |
416 |
a |
a |
a |
a |
No |
Home Health |
403 |
a |
a |
a |
a |
No |
Hospice |
437 |
a |
a |
a |
No |
No |
Laboratory |
401 |
a |
a |
a |
a |
β |
Nurse midwife |
a |
a |
a |
a |
No | |
Nurse practitioner |
a |
a |
a |
a |
β | |
Nursing Facility |
456 |
a |
a |
No |
No |
No |
Orthotic |
442 |
a |
a |
a |
a |
No |
Outpatient Hospital |
410 |
a |
a |
a |
a |
β |
Oxygen and Respiratory Therapy Equipment |
427 |
a |
a |
a |
a |
β |
Personal Care |
422 |
a |
a |
No |
No |
No |
Pharmacy |
406 |
a |
a |
a |
a |
β |
Physician |
433 |
a |
a |
a |
a |
β |
Podiatrist |
424 |
a |
a |
a |
a |
β |
Private Duty Nursing |
414 |
a |
a |
No |
No |
No |
Prosthetic |
428 |
a |
a |
a |
a |
β |
Rehabilitation Center |
430 |
a |
a |
a |
a |
β |
Renal Dialysis Clinic |
412 |
a |
a |
a |
a |
β |
Speech and Hearing Center |
413 |
a |
a |
a |
a |
β |
Therapy: Physical, |
432 |
a |
a |
a |
a |
β |
Transportation (Nonemergency) |
407 |
a |
a |
No |
No |
No |
Vision Care |
402 |
a |
a |
a |
a |
No |
X-ray/radiology |
a |
a |
a |
a |
β |
Source: Massachusetts Law Reform Institute, 2006